Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ken Williams, PhD's avatar

Simple yet profound analysis. An ideology and politics built on confirmation bias and false attribution bias.

Drew's avatar

I feel compelled to respond to this because I am so disappointed in NSL4A. While much of Mr Adolph’s analysis is strong, antisemitism comes through clear as a bell with his flippant comments about Israel, genocide and ethnic cleansing. It completely undermines his credibility for me and I hope for other officers who look at Israel’s response a little more critically. Antisemitism has no place in NSL4A. This man is supposedly an expert in international affairs and the use of military power. He knows or should know that the situation is so much more nuanced than he makes it out to be by his comments. And this article is about MAGA untruths? How about his (our) untruths? It makes me deeply distrustful of the actual agenda of NSL4A and fundamentally undermines my trust in the organization. Since when does the A in NSL4A stand for antisemitism?

Shame on us for putting our name on this. As I have told many people, if Canada were lobbing rockets into New York State, kidnapping US Border Patrol officers, raping and murdering American women and blowing up the occasional NYC bus, Ottawa would be a smoking ruin and Americans would be cheering. But God forbid the Jews defend themselves after a brutal and inhuman attack on Israeli citizens by Hamas terrorists, who are in actuality the Palestinian military. In my opinion, the Israelis responded with a military operation to end the ability of the government of Palestine to wage war on Israel in the same way the United States conducted a military operation to end the ability of the Japanese and the Germans to wage war on us. I cannot tell you just how deeply disappointing I find this coming from a group of leaders who served in our military and who are supposed to know better.

Andrew M Porter

LTC, US Army, Retired

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?